Compare
Certavi vs. manual citation checking
Every attorney verifies citations. The question is how. Here is what changes when you automate the process.
| Factor | Manual checking | Certavi |
|---|---|---|
| Time per brief | 2-4 hours for a 30-citation brief. Each citation requires opening Westlaw/LexisNexis, entering the cite, and confirming the match. | Under 5 minutes. Upload the brief, extraction + verification runs automatically, review the results. |
| Citation coverage | Depends on the reviewer's attention span. Footnotes, string cites, and parentheticals are frequently skipped under time pressure. | Every citation is extracted, including footnotes, parentheticals, and short-form references. Nothing is skipped. |
| Databases checked | Usually one (whichever database the attorney has open). Switching between Westlaw and CourtListener takes time. | Up to four: CourtListener, Westlaw, LexisNexis, and PACER. Checked in priority order you configure. |
| AI-generated citation detection | Requires the reviewer to notice something feels wrong. Fabricated citations with correct Bluebook formatting pass visual inspection. | Every citation is checked against a real database. A fabricated case returns NOT_FOUND regardless of how convincing it looks. |
| Audit trail | None, unless you manually log each check. Most attorneys do not keep verification records. | Every check is logged with the database queried, the response, and the timestamp. Immutable, append-only audit log. |
| Certificate | No standard format. You might send an email saying you checked the cites. | Signed PDF verification certificate with your bar number, the scope limitation, and a reference to the audit log. |
| Ongoing monitoring | You would need to re-check every cited case periodically. In practice, nobody does this. | Verified citations are auto-enrolled in docket monitoring. Three checks per day for reversals, new opinions, or status changes. |
| Cost | Attorney time at $200-600/hour. A 3-hour verification session costs $600-1,800 in billable time. | $39 per brief (Per Filing) or $199/month unlimited (Solo). Less than the cost of one billable hour. |
| Human error | Fatigue, distraction, and confirmation bias all reduce accuracy. The 47th citation gets less attention than the 1st. | Deterministic. The database query runs the same way for citation 1 and citation 47. |
Verification should not depend on how tired you are
Manual checking works. It has worked for decades. But it does not scale to AI-assisted drafting, where a tool can generate 50 citations in seconds. Certavi checks all 50 in under five minutes with a full audit trail.
Get started free